News

Compensation for Arbitrary Exclusion of L-1 Bidder from Tender Upheld: Patna High Court

The Hon’ble Patna High Court, in State of Bihar & Ors. v. Kamakshi Minakshi Construction Private Limited & Anr. (L.P.A. No. 1630 of 2018), decided on October 28, 2026, upheld the award of Rs. 5,00,000/- as compensation to a bidder who was arbitrarily excluded from a tender process on a ground not prescribed under the Notice Inviting Tender (“NIT”). The Hon’ble Court held that the subsequent award and substantial completion of the work under a fresh tender did not cure the illegality in the original tender process.

The dispute arose from a tender floated by the Bihar Rural Works Department pursuant to which the respondent was declared technically eligible and subsequently L-1. However, following a complaint made by a Member of the Legislative Assembly, the Tender Committee declared the respondent and the L-2 bidder ineligible on the ground that the stamp paper on which their affidavits had been executed had not been purchased in the names of the respective deponents. The tender was consequently cancelled and a fresh tender was issued.

The respondent challenged its exclusion before the Hon’ble High Court, which found that the ground of rejection was not stipulated in the NIT. Meanwhile, the fresh tender was awarded to another bidder and approximately 80% of the work had been completed. Taking these subsequent developments into consideration, the learned Single Judge, by judgment dated May 18, 2018, declined to restore the original tender in favour of the respondent but directed the State to pay Rs. 5,00,000/- as compensation.

The State challenged the compensation awarded, contending that the respondent had no vested right to the contract merely by being declared L-1 and had neither entered into a concluded contract nor established any actual pecuniary loss. It was further submitted that the respondent had been given an opportunity to participate in the fresh tender but had chosen not to do so.

The Hon’ble Court observed that the respondent had been declared ineligible on a ground having no basis in the tender conditions. It further noted that the State had fairly admitted that the NIT contained no such requirement. The Hon’ble Court held that the subsequent award of the contract could not cure the illegality in the original tender process, particularly since the fresh tender proceedings had been made subject to the outcome of the pending writ petition.

The Hon’ble Court upheld the compensation awarded by the learned Single Judge, observing that the relief had been appropriately moulded by balancing the established illegality in the original tender process against the substantial progress of the public work. It held that the compensation was not contractual damages but a discretionary relief granted in exercise of writ jurisdiction.

Accordingly, the Hon’ble Patna High Court dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal and upheld the direction requiring the State to pay Rs. 5,00,000/- as compensation to the respondent.