News

Unreasoned Tender Cancellation Sustained Where Bidder Was Technically Ineligible: Allahabad High Court

The Hon’ble Allahabad High Court, in M/s Balaji Construction v. State of U.P. & Ors. (Writ-C No. 23168 of 2026), decided on October 8, 2026, examined the legality of cancellation of tender proceedings and rejection of a bidder on grounds of inadequate work experience. The Hon’ble Court reiterated that State authorities must act fairly and transparently in contractual matters and that tender conditions relating to essential eligibility requirements must be strictly complied with.

The dispute arose from tenders floated by the Agra Development Authority for internal development works at Sindhupuram (Township-1) and Yamunapuram (Township-4). The petitioner participated in both tenders and was initially shown as technically qualified. However, the Authority subsequently cancelled both tender proceedings on April 25, 2026, citing unforeseen circumstances and initiated fresh tender proceedings. The petitioner challenged the cancellation, alleging arbitrariness and favouritism.

The petitioner contended that the cancellation order was arbitrary and devoid of reasons. It further alleged that the Authority had manipulated the tender process to favour selected contractors and that its technical bid had been wrongly rejected despite possessing the requisite experience. The respondents, however, submitted that the petitioner had been erroneously included in the list of technically qualified bidders despite lacking the required experience in internal development works, including RCC works, sewerage systems and drainage infrastructure.

The Hon’ble Court observed that the cancellation order merely referred to unforeseen circumstances without specifying any reasons or identifying any contractual provision authorising such cancellation. Relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, (1978) 1 SCC 405, the Hon’ble Court held that an order must stand on its own reasoning and cannot be supplemented by subsequent affidavits. Accordingly, the Hon’ble Court held that the cancellation order, being devoid of reasons, was arbitrary.

However, upon examining the original tender records, the Hon’ble Court found that the petitioner had been declared technically ineligible by the Technical Evaluation Committee for lacking the requisite experience in similar works. The experience certificate submitted by the petitioner related to widening and strengthening of a road and did not establish experience in sewerage and drainage infrastructure. The Court also declined to consider additional documents produced through a supplementary affidavit which had not formed part of the original bid submission.

The Hon’ble Court further held that experience in road construction could not be equated with the specialised experience required for internal township development works. Such experience constituted an essential eligibility condition which could not be diluted. Further, notwithstanding the absence of reasons in the cancellation order, the Hon’ble Court found from the original records substantial justification for cancellation of the tender proceedings, since an ineligible bidder had been shown as technically qualified, thereby tainting the process, and held that the Authority’s decision was neither discriminatory nor mala fide.

With respect to the challenge to the show cause notice issued against the petitioner for allegedly interfering with the tender process, the Hon’ble Court held that interference at the show cause stage is permissible only in limited circumstances, including mala fides, predetermined action or patent lack of jurisdiction. Finding no such grounds, the Hon’ble Court declined to interfere with the notice and left it open to the Authority to proceed in accordance with law.

Accordingly, the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that the petitioner had failed to establish any illegality in the rejection of its technical bid or any ground warranting interference with the tender cancellation.