The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) has amended the performance-rating criteria applicable to Authority Engineer (AE) and Independent Engineer (IE) consultancy firms engaged in National Highway projects. The amendment introduces a deduction for catastrophic failures occurring in projects under their supervision, extending performance-based accountability beyond contractors and concessionaires to engineering consultants.
Under the revised criteria, 20 marks will be deducted from the individual project score of the AE or IE consultancy firm for each catastrophic failure. The deduction will be applied even if it results in a negative project score, which will then be taken into account while calculating the firm’s overall rating.
The measure builds upon the Ministry’s earlier introduction of a 30-mark deduction for contractors and concessionaires for each catastrophic failure. The corresponding amendment for AE and IE firms addresses the role played by these consultants in design review, construction supervision, quality control and safety monitoring, as representatives of the project authority at the site.
The revised criteria are intended to make engineering consultants more accountable for failures occurring during project execution and operation. The Ministry has directed the concerned implementing agencies to assess AE and IE consultancy firms in accordance with the amended framework, with NHAI serving as the nodal agency for undertaking the ratings.
The amendment has commercial implications for engineering consultancy firms, particularly those undertaking highway projects through joint ventures or associations. Since performance ratings may influence eligibility and opportunities in future government procurement, catastrophic failures can now affect not only the contractor or concessionaire but also the professional standing and future bidding prospects of the consultants responsible for project supervision and quality assurance.


