News

Bengaluru Civil Court: Employer Cannot Prevent Former Employee Joining a Competitor Citing Confidentiality Obligations

In M/s. EOX Vantage Private Limited v. Shruthi B.S. (O.S. No. 3154/2023), decided on October 6, 2026, an Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, dismissed EOX Vantage Private Limited’s suit seeking to restrain its former employee from allegedly disclosing confidential information, soliciting clients and recruiting employees. It observed that an employer ordinarily cannot prevent a former employee from joining a competitor or using general skills, experience and knowledge merely by characterising a restriction as a confidentiality obligation. The Court found that the company had not established the alleged misconduct on the evidence and was not entitled to a permanent injunction.

Background

EOX Vantage alleged that the defendant, formerly an Assistant Manager–Operations, had transferred rate cards, contracts and other business information to her personal email over three to five years. It further alleged that, after resigning, she had acted with other former employees to disclose information to competitors and solicit its employees and clients. It relied on non-disclosure and non-solicitation agreements, an internal investigation report, electronic evidence and an FIR registered under Sections 66 and 66C of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and Sections 408, 504 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The defendant denied the allegations, contending that the suit was intended to harass her.

Section 27 and Confidential Information

The Court referred to Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, under which agreements restraining a person from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business are void to the extent of the restraint. At the same time, the Court recognised that employers can protect legitimate confidential information, including trade secrets, proprietary source code, confidential pricing, customer data and technical know-how, and observed that an injunction could be sought to prevent the disclosure of trade secrets. The Court nevertheless described the non-disclosure agreement in the case as illegal under the applicable law.

The Court’s Findings on The Evidence

The Court found that the plaintiff had failed to establish the defendant’s involvement in the alleged disclosure of confidential information or solicitation. The investigation report contained no specific allegation against her, and the employees whose communications and screenshots were relied upon were not examined. The persons responsible for the forensic investigation remained unidentified, and the company’s CEO and COO, who were part of the investigation team, did not testify.

The Court further questioned how the personal email of a defendant in a connected case had been accessed and noted deficiencies in the certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 accompanying the electronic evidence. It observed that the company had not established that the defendant’s subsequent employer was a competitor, examined the relevant clients or produced a Chartered Accountant’s report substantiating the alleged loss, and noted that employees had been permitted to access company data while working from home during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Outcome

Noting that the FIR had not resulted in a charge sheet, the Court observed that the circumstances surrounding the defendant’s relieving letter and the FIR raised suspicions about the company’s intention to prevent the defendant from joining a competing company. Finding the allegations and claimed losses unproven, the Court described the suit as speculative and declined to grant a permanent injunction, dismissing the suit with costs.